Insuring Ohio
Families, Farms, & Businesses
For 35+ Years.

Trusty Insurance is an independent agency committed to you.

Our
Carriers

Allstate logo
Wayne Insurance Group logo
Mennonite Mutual logo
Foremost Insurance Group logo
National General An Allstate Company logo
Metlife logo

We partner with strategic insurance carriers to offer a wide range of insurance solutions at competitive prices with personalized services, including home, auto, life, business, farm and crop.

Home

Auto

Life

Business

Commercial

Farm

Flood

Contractor

Recreational

Boat

Mobile Home & RV Park

Pet

Annuities

We Work For You.

As an independent insurance agency, we do not work for an insurance company– we work for you. We are on your side when you have a loss and follow through to see that you get fair, prompt payment.

Trusty Insurance provides our family of customers with a personalized insurance package and ensure that all claims are handled promptly and paid fairly, while saving you money and providing the best customer service humanly possible.

Our staff is not only licensed and trained in the field of insurance — they are also friendly, courteous, and responsible. We get to know each and every insured and want you to feel that we are friends, not just insurance agents. You, as our client, will never be treated as a mere number in a large agency. You will be afforded the best service humanly possible. Your input on how to serve you better is always more than welcome. The service we provide for our clients is what has made our agency one of the fastest growing insurance agencies in the Wilmington and Germantown areas.

Risk management is foremost at our agency. We identify your specific needs, help you determine which coverage is the best choice for your situation, and chart a well defined course for the future.

Trusted Choice Agency</p>
<p>National Association of Professional Insurance Agents</p>
<p>Ohio Insurance Agents

35+ Years of Experience

Locally-Owned

Customized Plans

Low Rates

Get Your Free Insurance Quote Today

We provide personalized insurance packages to fit your unique needs.

Here’s What Our Clients Are Saying About Us

“Trusty Insurance’s continual checks to verify that I’m getting the best deal possible are an absolute plus. The big insurance companies seem content with letting their loyal customers continue to pay high premiums when it’s not necessary. I’ve not found that to be true with Trusty.”

Jeff

“Five stars all the way! We have had a very successful working relationship with Trusty Insurance and hope to do so for a long time to come. They have always been ready with good, solid answers and advice for any of our questions. I would gladly recommend their services to others.”

Todd

“Your staff is very friendly and accommodating. They are always fast to take care of or answer any questions, and always get back with you promptly. It’s almost like I’m your only customer and all your attention and effort is spent on my concerns. Thank you all so much!”

Don

Request Your Insurance Quote

Request a Quote - Home Footer
Name
Name
First
Last

No coverage can be bound through this website including email and/or voicemail messages.

Trusty Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving Wilmington, Germantown, and the surrounding Ohio areas with 35+ years of experience.

Wilmington Office

Germantown Office